I think it's hard pressed to compare to Madden, of course, which is the by far the most popular football game on the 360. Metacritic has it at 54 out of 100, with 29 critic reviews. Regular users gave it a 7.6 our of 10 though, so if you can get it used for a decent price, I'd say that it's a pretty safe bet. I typically give more value to the regular user reviews personally. If you do get it, let us know how you like it!