I actually liked the older one. All the green and dark colors fit the Xbox conversation very well. I don't have a problem with the new look, but I did enjoy the old theme. Anyhow, it's the content that makes a forum I think though.
This one is just as great as the old one. I think it's a bit too much gray for my taste, but the shades of green and the overall aspect make up for it. Anyways, change is a very good thing once in a while. Keep up the good work, guys!
I was also surprised, when I logged on here, and the theme was different. I had to check the url, to make sure I was at the right place. I like the cleaner look of this theme, but I feel like the other theme fit with the colors of the Xbox.